Top 10 Nonprofit Consulting Firms (With Grade A Services)

FREE Consultation: Before you get started, make sure you have the right software! Request a consultation with OneCause to see how we can assist your fundraising strategy today!

Managing a nonprofit can be a lot like building a house; when one area isn’t holding up well, chances are the rest of your foundation will start to crumble. That’s why a nonprofit consulting firm is always a trusted ally when it comes to strengthening the sum of your nonprofit’s parts.

These professionals aren’t looking to dish out temporary solutions, but rather to ensure long-term success for your organization by planning and executing a tailored nonprofit strategy.

With that said, researching the right nonprofit consulting firm for your individual needs can be a hassle — which is why we’ve decided to bring the top recommendations to you!

Before you get started with this list, ensure that your fundraising software is up to par. After all, the consulting firm that’s right for your organization should be empowered by software that streamlines your efforts (instead of lackluster software that leaves your frontline fundraisers with the urge to pull out their hair).

That said, let’s take a look at our key contenders!

[go_pricing id=”nonprofit_consulting_firms”]

The right consultant can take your organization’s efforts to the next level! Ready to get started? Use the table above to navigate the page or jump to exactly what you’re looking for. Let’s go:

#1 DNL OMNIMEDIA — BEST CHOICE FOR WEB DESIGN AND MARKETING

HOW THIS NONPROFIT CONSULTING FIRM CAN HELP YOUR NONPROFIT

DNL OmniMedia is a nonprofit consulting firm that uses expert technologies to streamline your nonprofit’s web development and marketing initiatives.

This team’s technical strategies are both easy to utilize and seamlessly integrate your web, mobile, and data solutions.  

With DNL OmniMedia, your organization is guaranteed to achieve fast and efficient nonprofit communications and digital outreach.

MOST POPULAR NONPROFIT CONSULTING SERVICES

DNL OmniMedia is a leading authority in nonprofit:

  • Web design and development.
  • Digital and event marketing.
  • Donor management.
  • Content and data migration.

They can also help your nonprofit customize and configure software to your liking by utilizing relationships with digital platforms like Blackbaud Luminate, Salsa, Drupal, and Salesforce.

WHY WE RECOMMEND THIS NONPROFIT CONSULTING FIRM

DNL OmniMedia takes a personalized approach to revamping your digital operations by taking the time to get to know your nonprofit’s mission and goals first.

Their team also embraces working with a variety of nonprofit causes such as higher education, faith-based, healthcare, animal welfare, and much more.

With high-profile clients like the ALS Association and Big Brothers and Big Sisters of New York City, DNL OmniMedia is committed to making your philanthropic communications as fluid and effective as possible.

DNL OmniMedia is a nonprofit consulting firm that ensures better web design and nonprofit marketing.

LEARN MORE ABOUT DNL OMNIMEDIA

#2 AVERILL FUNDRAISING SOLUTIONS — BEST CHOICE FOR FULL SERVICE CONSULTING

HOW THIS NONPROFIT CONSULTING FIRM CAN HELP YOUR NONPROFIT

With more than 75 years in combined fundraising consulting experience, the Averill Fundraising Solutions team will work with your team on every step of your capital campaigns to ensure long-term success.

You can rely on Averill’s leadership team for the height of ethical practice in the industry.

MOST POPULAR NONPROFIT CONSULTING SERVICES

As a full-service fundraising consulting firm, Averill can take on a wide array of projects. Most common, though, are:

  • Campaign/annual fund direction.
  • Campaign planning/feasibility studies.
  • Leadership learning.
  • Executive search.

Whichever service you choose, you’re sure to get a healthy return on investment — Averill subscribes to a variety of industry-standard ethical practices.

WHY WE RECOMMEND THIS NONPROFIT CONSULTING FIRM

Averill has a wealth of experience across the entire nonprofit sector, so no matter what you’re fundraising for, there’s a solution for you there. Most notably, Averill partners with faith-based, education, and healthcare organizations.

Whatever project you partner with Averill to complete, the firm will look beyond the immediate concerns in both directions.

Averil plans for success in your campaigns and then ensures the structures and strategies in place will lead you to success again in the future.

LEARN MORE ABOUT AVERILL FUNDRAISING SOLUTIONS

Aly Sterling Philanthropy can help with executive search and fundraising.

#3 ALY STERLING PHILANTHROPY — BEST CHOICE FOR EXECUTIVE SEARCH AND FUNDRAISING

HOW THIS NONPROFIT CONSULTING FIRM CAN HELP YOUR NONPROFIT

Aly Sterling Philanthropy is an established nonprofit consulting firm that provides hands-on assistance for enhancing your nonprofit’s executive search and fundraising strategies.

In particular, their services help organizations reshape donor giving tactics and organize an exceptional staff and board.

Above all, their top priority is to create sustainable solutions that grow with your nonprofit.

MOST POPULAR NONPROFIT CONSULTING SERVICES

Aly Sterling Philanthropy is a one-stop-shop for all things:

  • Executive search.
  • Fundraising solutions.
  • Strategic planning.
  • Board governance.

They also offer workshops on board development and fundraising techniques as well as a nonprofit job board for executive search clients.

\

WHY WE RECOMMEND THIS NONPROFIT CONSULTING FIRM

A member of The Giving Institute, Aly Sterling Philanthropy is responsive to your needs and provides cost-effective solutions for growing your nonprofit.

Their team represents decades of experience crafting customized game plans for organizations all of all shapes and sizes.

To top it off, this nationwide firm raised millions of dollars for Midwest nonprofits in Ohio, Indiana, and Southeast Michigan.

Aly Sterling Philanthropy is a nonprofit consulting firm that handles executive search with a tailor-made process.

LEARN MORE ABOUT ALY STERLING PHILANTHROPY

Ter Molen is our top fundraising consulting firm for capital campaigns.

#4 TER MOLEN WATKINS AND BRANDT

HOW THIS NONPROFIT CONSULTING FIRM CAN HELP YOUR NONPROFIT

Ter Molen Watkins & Brandt is a nonprofit consulting firm that provides expert fundraising counsel for executing a memorable (and lucrative) capital campaign. They also assist in developing other nonprofit giving areas, corporate and government funding, and volunteer and staffing growth.

Their capital campaign consultants walk your nonprofit through every milestone from feasibility studies and soliciting donations to campaign leadership and marketing.

MOST POPULAR NONPROFIT CONSULTING SERVICES

Ter Molen Watkins & Brandt have consulting strengths in:

  • Capital campaign coordination.
  • Fundraising feasibility studies.
  • Fundraising analytics.
  • Annual campaign development.
  • Board and volunteer leadership development.

This nonprofit consulting firm has partnerships with The Giving Institute and DonorSearch as well as a virtual nonprofit education center.

Ter Molen Watkins and Brandt are a nonprofit consulting firm that specializes in capital campaigns and offers free nonprofit resources.

LEARN MORE ABOUT TER MOLEN WATKINS AND BRANDT

Big Duck can consult with you on branding and communications.

#5 BIG DUCK

HOW THIS NONPROFIT CONSULTING FIRM CAN HELP YOUR NONPROFIT

A New York City-based consultant, Big Duck uses smart communications to generate funds and awareness for nonprofit causes. This nonprofit consulting firm reaches new donors by telling your nonprofit’s story with personalized branding, fundraising, and awareness campaigns.

Their market research tool, Brandraising Benchmark, is particularly useful for measuring public awareness and engagement with your nonprofit in addition to donor analytics.

MOST POPULAR NONPROFIT CONSULTING SERVICES

Big Duck specializes in:

  • Marketing and communications.
  • Brand development.
  • Fundraising campaigns.
  • Recruitment strategies.

Big Duck’s services are also designed to strengthen your nonprofit’s in-house communications with workshops in staff searches and structure, planning, and assessments.

For a breakdown of Big Ducks’s nonprofit promotional pyramid, see the diagram below.

Big Duck is a nonprofit consulting firm that strengthens nonprofit branding and communications.

LEARN MORE ABOUT BIG DUCK

#6 BRIAN LACY AND ASSOCIATES

HOW THIS NONPROFIT CONSULTING FIRM CAN HELP YOUR NONPROFIT

Brian Lacy and Associates is a nonprofit consulting firm with services rooted in fine-tuning a nonprofit’s annual giving strategy. They also have experience in cultivating prospect research and marketing and communications.

Their annual giving consulting starts with conducting a development audit of your existing plan before crafting a new strategy to improve your nonprofit’s data management, donor stewardship, and more.

MOST POPULAR NONPROFIT CONSULTING SERVICES

Brain Lacy and Associates primarily offers:

  • Annual giving.
  • Audits.
  • Temporary management programs.

Brian Lacy and Associates views annual giving as a nonprofit’s lifeblood and has helped over 400 nonprofits raise more than $1 billion in philanthropic support.

LEARN MORE ABOUT BRIAN LACY AND ASSOCIATES

#7 ASPIRE RESEARCH GROUP

HOW THIS NONPROFIT CONSULTING FIRM CAN HELP YOUR NONPROFIT

Aspire Research Group, led by Jen Filla, guides organizations through prospect research with efficient tools and in-depth training. This nonprofit consulting firm lives by 8 core principles which reflect strong communications, personal interactions, and evolving goals.

Aspire Research Group is mainly known for their prospect profile services with qualification, solicitation, and verification options for donors and frontline fundraisers.

MOST POPULAR NONPROFIT CONSULTING SERVICES

Aspire Research Group offers services ranging in:

  • Prospect identification.
  • Donor cultivation and asking strategies.
  • Relationship/prospect management.
  • Major giving enhancement.

Their versatile packages allow both large and small nonprofits to better identify prospects, develop tailored solicitation strategies, and exceed their major giving goals.

LEARN MORE ABOUT ASPIRE RESEARCH GROUP

#8 FIRED-UP FUNDRAISING

HOW THIS NONPROFIT CONSULTING FIRM CAN HELP YOUR NONPROFIT

Championed by fundraising expert Gail Perry, Fired-Up Fundraising offers nonprofits stellar services aimed at boosting major giving, capital campaigns, and board development. Her board training workshops motivate and organize your nonprofit board to build up fundraising efforts.

Gail Perry’s Major Gifts Coaching and Mentoring Program is also a must-know, step-by-step resource for cultivating lasting major donor relationships. 

MOST POPULAR NONPROFIT CONSULTING SERVICES

Fired-Up Fundraising offers nonprofits:

  • Major giving training and growth.
  • Board development.
  • Feasibility study management.
  • Capital campaign coaching and workshops.

Gail Perry provides free fundraising tools to nonprofit professionals and a series of instructive fundraising videos on the Fired-Up Fundraising website.

LEARN MORE ABOUT FIRED-UP FUNDRAISING

If you're planning an event, Westfall Gold is there to help.

#9 WESTFALL GOLD

HOW THIS NONPROFIT CONSULTING FIRM CAN HELP YOUR NONPROFIT

Westfall Gold is a leading nonprofit event consultant whose major donor event strategy has been perfected over 20 years. Their event production and creative communications succeed in crafting ideal environments for your nonprofit to connect with donors.

Most importantly, this nonprofit consulting firm nails finer event details by assigning a senior consultant to work with you every step of the way.

MOST POPULAR NONPROFIT CONSULTING SERVICES

Westfall Gold are certified experts in:

  • Event consulting.
  • Event services.
  • Event speakers.
  • Even production.
  • Creative Services.

Overall, this firm’s mission is to ensure donors have an unforgettable time at your fundraising event with five-star event consulting services.

LEARN MORE ABOUT WESTFALL GOLD

#10 JEFFREY BYRNE AND ASSOCIATES

HOW THIS NONPROFIT CONSULTING FIRM CAN HELP YOUR NONPROFIT

Jeffrey Byrne and Associates is a nonprofit consulting firm that aids organizations with all manner of fundraising consulting initiatives. They also help nonprofits with advancement planning, prospect research analytics, and marketing and communications.

This firm’s primary service is their Futures Program which involves planning and building a lucrative nonprofit planned giving program from the ground up.

MOST POPULAR NONPROFIT CONSULTING SERVICES

Jeffrey Byrne and Associates are well-versed in:

  • Planned giving.
  • Major giving.
  • Capital campaign coordination.
  • Fundraising feasibility studies.
  • Annual campaign development.

Jeffrey Byrne and Associates also serves a wealth of nonprofit areas such as education, faith-based, healthcare, arts, culture and humanities, and more.

Jeffrey Byrne and Associates is a nonprofit consulting firm that boosts nonprofit planned giving with their Futures Program.

LEARN MORE ABOUT JEFFREY BYRNE AND ASSOCIATES


By partnering with the right nonprofit consulting firm, there’s no telling how far your organization will go to achieve your long-term philanthropy goals.

For more information on nonprofit consulting services, check out these expert resources: